Throughout my career I have had many opportunities to welcome students and other educators into my home for tours, observations and practicum placements. I have found these visits to be enlightening and I am certain that I learn just as much or more than any of the ‘students’.
Sometimes visitors are here outside of regular working hours simply to see my childcare environment and get ideas for their own programs. When there are no children present we have plenty of time for discussions and often the visitors will ask why I have things arranged the way they are. Even as I answer their questions I may also begin to ponder ‘Is this really the best way or could I do it differently?’
The visitors who come for ‘observations’ have the most difficulty and sometimes it is downright hilarious. Usually they’ve been instructed to ‘observe’ the children and/or me but not ‘interfere or interact’ with us. LOL The second they entered the room they became the children’s favourite toy. “Who are you? What are you writing? Can I have your pen/some paper? I drew a flower. I have Darth Vader on my shirt. Do you like light sabers? We aren’t supposed to hit with toys. I’m hungry, did you bring a snack? …. It doesn’t end and honestly I doubt anything they observe would resemble a ‘normal’ day.
My favourite visitors are the Early Childhood Education students here for their practicum placement. They come for longer periods of time – usually six full days. They are expected to join in and even plan activities. They get to know us and we get to know them. All of the practicum students that have come here were part of the Red River College Workplace program which means they already have experience working in licensed childcare facilities. Usually these students have only had experience working in centres but have expressed an interest in learning more about family child care as a possible career choice in the future.
They already understand child development and guidance. Many are well acquainted with licensing regulations, policies and procedures – at least in the centres in which they work. Some have already worked in childcare for many, many years as childcare assistants. Really there is little or nothing I could teach them about doing their current job. However, they are here to learn about family childcare and for most of them that is something new – and very different from what they currently do.
The first comment I hear when these practicum students arrive is almost always ‘I can’t believe how quiet it is’. Yes, even though I may not always find it ‘quiet’ here, in comparison to working in a centre it is very quiet. Sometimes I even find it too quiet – especially when I have a particularly independent group or there are some children absent. There are days that I am tempted to initiate new activities simply because I am bored – I have to stop and consider if the children would actually benefit from my activity or if I would be interrupting a wonderful child-led experience in order for me to feel more productive.
Of course the play space also excites many of the students – especially the use of environmental guidance so I/they don’t have to constantly provide direct guidance. I love that the students recognize this. 🙂 They also note how easily the children choose, engage, and clean-up activities with little or no assistance from me. We often share stories about behaviour issues we’ve experienced at our respective programs and how changes to the environment have/could address them. I think that the ability to control the environment is what draws many centre staff to family childcare – they see issues at their workplaces, have ideas that could help but for whatever reason are not permitted to implement them.
However, I don’t feel that these practicum students ever experience ‘real’ family childcare when they are here.
Firstly, they are only here for eight hour days, not the eleven I normally spend with the children each day. The college also expects that I will give them breaks – many of the students choose to forego their break and leave earlier instead. There was one who never wanted to leave and often stayed longer than required but still not my full day. One insisted on taking her lunch break at lunch time – the busiest part of my day – instead of joining the children and I for lunch. She spent an hour sitting in her car and returned when I had the kitchen clean and all the children settled in for their naps. In my opinion there were several factors that made me doubt she was suited for ANY position in childcare.
Secondly, these students are never alone here or in their regular workplace. Certainly there are times when I busy myself elsewhere and observe the student engaging with the children independently but they are not truly ‘alone’. There is nothing I can do to allow the students to experience what it is like to be the only one responsible for doing everything all day, every day. As much as they may think that they would love to be their own boss, that freedom comes with a whole lot more responsibility and time commitment than their current jobs.
Then there is all the other stuff – the evening and weekend stuff when the children are gone. The cleaning, the paperwork, contacting prospective parents, meetings, interviews and more – the students see none of that. Are they prepared for the challenge to their work/life balance when they work from home – and what about their families? The ‘family‘ portion of family child care is a HUGE factor and many providers who choose FCC specifically to stay at home with their own children also discover they prefer working in a centre and can’t wait to ‘get their house back’.
I have had a couple students who claim to understand how much time is required for FCC but then remark that they aren’t actually planning to work in their ‘real’ home because they ‘won’t do that to their family’. They want to rent/buy a second house or use some other space away from their true home. We sit down and review some regulations and do some financial calculations for FCC income vs expenses for a separate space. Even if the regulations allowed it, financially this is not a viable option.
Family childcare homes are not centres – they cannot be run the same nor can they be compared to centres. Not all ECE’s with experience in centres are equipped for working in homes and many FCC Providers would not survive working in centres. Still, there is a lot we have in common and there is a lot we can learn from each other.
My experiences with mentoring practicum students has been enlightening. I have observed how the behavior of the children in my care, in my environment, changes with the addition of another caregiver. I’ve been able to reflect on whether it something I do or the student does that influences the behaviours. I’m also certain that even though there are days when I could use an extra set of hands to get everything done, I am still much happier working alone. That’s not the case for everyone – some ECE’s need the larger groups and daily interaction with colleagues and family childcare may not be the best fit for them.